Regional Economic Patterns · 7 min read

Thompson Park Golf Course: One Bidder, a Five-Year Ask and a State Law Change

Watertown's request for a private operator for the Thompson Park Golf Course drew one proposal. On Nov. 9 the bidder, CPA and former golf course owner Andrea Doane, pitched $3,000 a month and said she'd prefer a five-year lease. A lease also needs a state law. Here is the background, the offer, and what comes next.

Listen

  • Read aloud One AI voice reads the article 10 min

AI-generated audio. Charts and tables are on the page.

WBA · Watertown Business Advisory
0:00

The short version

  • One bid: the city's request for proposals to lease and run the Thompson Park Golf Course drew one proposal, from Jefferson County Business Services, Inc., led by Watertown CPA Andrea Doane, a former golf course owner.
  • The offer: $3,000 a month plus 3% of any revenue above last year's. Her written proposal covers one season, but at the Nov. 9 work session she said she would prefer a five-year lease. City residents' rates would stay the same.
  • Negotiate only: on Oct. 19 the City Council voted 5–0 to let staff negotiate. Nothing is signed. Any lease comes back to the Council for a vote.
  • State law: because the course sits on city parkland, the city says it needs the State Legislature's permission to lease it. The Council voted 5–0 to ask for that.

After three money-losing seasons running Thompson Park's golf course itself, Watertown is trying to hand it to a private operator. On Oct. 19 the City Council authorized talks with the only bidder and asked Albany for the legal power to sign a lease. On Nov. 9 the bidder came to a Council work session and made her pitch. Here is how the city got here, what's on offer, and what has to happen before anyone tees off under a new operator.

How we got here

When What happened
2023 The city buys the former Watertown Golf Club, the 18-hole course in Thompson Park, from developer Michael E. Lundy for $3.4 million (Watertown Daily Times, Apr. 3, 2026)
2023–2025 The city runs the course through Parks and Recreation. It lost $623,559 in 2023 and 2024 combined and $87,085 in 2025 (same article). WWNY put the 2025 loss at about $100,000 (WWNY, Apr. 3, 2026)
Spring 2026 At budget sessions, a Council majority informally agrees the city can't keep running the course after this season. The budget funds it through October (WWNY)
April 2026 David "DJ" Marconi, who runs the clubhouse restaurant (DJ's at the Park), proposes leasing the course and clubhouse from Jan. 1, 2027 (WDT)
May 2026 The city says it must run a formal request for proposals to see who else is interested (WDT, May 8, 2026)
Oct. 13, 2026 Proposals due for RFP #2026-11 (city calendar). The City Manager tells the Council that evening that one proposal came in "right before the timeline closed" (work session video, 1:50:03; minutes)
Oct. 19, 2026 Council votes 5–0 on Res. 9 (negotiate) and Res. 10 (ask the state) (minutes)
Nov. 9, 2026 The bidder presents to the Council at a work session; no vote (minutes; video, 34:27)

Who bid

The city's documents name the bidder as Jefferson County Business Services, Inc. (Oct. 19 agenda, Res. 9). At the Nov. 9 work session, the company was represented by Andrea Doane, who introduced herself as the former owner of the Rustic Golf Club on Pillar Point and runs a local CPA firm, with her son Sean, whose business is Mulligan's on Pillar Point. Her daughter Erica joined by phone to talk about the restaurant (minutes; video, 35:29). It is a different bidder from the clubhouse restaurant's current operator, who proposed a lease in April. The written proposal itself is still not in any published agenda packet.

What Council members said about it on Oct. 19: Mayor Pierce said the bidder has "business experience, financial experience, golf industry experience" (video, 55:06). Council Member Kimball said the proposal shows experience running golf courses, and noted it covers the course, clubhouse, restaurant and bar together, which "has not been the case for the last couple years" (53:12).

What the Council approved, and what it didn't

Res. 9 lets the City Manager name a staff team, with the City Attorney, to review the proposal, meet the bidder and negotiate a lease beginning in 2027. It "authorizes negotiations only" and is not an award or acceptance. Any lease must come back to the Council and still needs state approval. Staff also suggested inviting the bidder to a Council work session to present the proposal (agenda memo).

The Nov. 9 pitch

Ms. Doane told the Council she was looking for guidance on how to proceed (minutes). What she offered:

Rent $3,000 a month, "which I'm still sticking with," plus 3% of any revenue above last year's as extra rent (video, 41:17)
Term The written proposal covers one season. "There is an option for a five-year lease," she said, and she would prefer five years, but wanted to learn the course's customers before taking on the risk (51:15). The one-year idea is about equipment: "I don't want to put $250,000 in carts for one year" (50:54)
Golfers City residents' rates stay at current levels. She would lease 20 to 30 gas carts, since electric carts struggle on the hills
Reporting A maintenance schedule, a monthly report on finances and rounds played, and a year-end report (48:14)
Restaurant "Mulligan's at the Park," with tournaments, holiday events and Friday nights. She asked for a signed lease by mid-January, because liquor license and food permit applications can take months (46:43)

Her concerns: the irrigation system ("quite pricey to fix," and a city decision), whether the clubhouse would pass a health inspection given its condition, prepaid items such as sponsorships, and whether a lease would make the operator owe property taxes on the course.

What Council members said:

  • Shoen said a one-year lease gives a tenant too little stability or reason to keep up the improvements city staff have made, and stressed long-term viability with limited taxpayer exposure. He also said the course needs enough carts for tournaments, since shortages hurt past events.
  • Garrabrant agreed a longer lease would bring stability.
  • Kimball disclosed that Ms. Doane's accounting firm has prepared his taxes for the last few years and said it would not affect his view of the proposal.
  • City Manager Wagenaar said staff will review the proposal and hold meetings to gather answers, then bring the results to the Council (minutes).

What Council members asked for on Oct. 19

  • A seat at the table. Garrabrant asked that a Council member join the negotiating team, even just to "observe and report," because the course has "a particular level of scrutiny in terms of transparency" (48:14). Osborne, Shoen and Mayor Pierce agreed; the Mayor asked for a volunteer (minutes).
  • A longer term. Shoen asked why the term was one year. City Manager Eric Wagenaar said a longer lease "was one of our objectives," but one year "was what they offered," and from a business view he could understand a bidder wanting a trial first (49:04). Shoen worried that with the course "in phenomenal shape," a one-year operator could do minimal upkeep: "you get one year to burn that up." He said he wasn't saying that would happen, but "short-term leases have the tendency to create issues like that" (49:59).
  • Organic-only grass care. Shoen said the proposal's "organic greens maintenance" concerns him because "it does take chemicals to do a very good job on greens." He added, "I don't have a problem allowing a negotiation to start" (51:17). Wagenaar called it good feedback for the negotiations, including the course's condition at hand-back; City Attorney Frateschi noted the Council votes on any final deal (52:18).
  • The other view on one year. Kimball said he was "very pleased that we got anybody to put in a bid," calling the course "a set up for public failure if there ever was one." A one-year trial "makes perfect business sense for them... maybe that's not ideal for us, but I think it's what we got" (53:12).

Why a lease needs a state law

New York treats city parks as held in a public trust for everyone. Under that rule, a city generally can't sell, lease or give up parkland for other uses without an act of the State Legislature signed by the Governor. That's called parkland alienation, and it applies to every city, town, village and county park. Recreational facilities such as golf courses can count as parkland (NYS Parks handbook on parkland alienation).

Not every deal triggers it. Courts have allowed a revocable license to run a city golf course without state approval, where the city could end it at will and controlled fees and hours. A lease giving an operator exclusive possession, with no cancel-at-will clause, has been held to need legislation (same handbook). The city's Res. 10 says this lease would let a private company run a facility on dedicated parkland, so it needs the Legislature (agenda). Worth knowing: in spring 2026, the City Manager was reported saying a lease, unlike a sale, would not need state approval (WDT, Apr. 3). The city's position in October is that it does.

The state handbook says such leases usually require the course stay public on fair terms, end if it stops being a park use, and put net lease proceeds into park improvements rather than the general fund. Watertown has done this before: a 2009 state law let the city lease fairgrounds parkland to the Watertown Family YMCA (Senate bill S245, signed 2009).

What happens next

  • Negotiations. Staff, the City Attorney and a Council member work out terms with the bidder. Open questions include the length of the lease, who pays for the irrigation system and clubhouse repairs, and property taxes. The bidder wants a signed lease by mid-January.
  • A state bill. Watertown's state legislators would need to introduce a bill. The Legislature's next session begins in January. Under Senate and Assembly rules, the bill can't reach a floor vote until the Council passes a formal Home Rule Request for that specific bill (same State Parks handbook).
  • Council vote on the lease. Any final lease comes back to the Council. It is still possible no deal is reached.
  • The 2027 season depends on both the lease and the state bill. The city has not published a target date for either.

Disclosure: Watertown Business Advisory is a registered City of Watertown vendor. We have no role in the golf course lease.


Sources: City of Watertown Oct. 19, 2026 agenda, minutes and video; Nov. 9 work session minutes and video; Oct. 13 work session minutes and video. Quotes are from the video; votes are from the official minutes.

Thinking about bidding on a city lease or contract? Talk to us.

Disclosure: WBA is a registered City of Watertown vendor. We don't write about solicitations we bid on or projects we're paid to work on. How we keep our coverage independent.

Want help applying this?

If this sounds like your organization, tell us what's going on. We usually reply within two business days with a suggestion on where to start.

Get in touch